Home / Articles / The Leafs' Special Teams Stopped Bailing Them Out
The Leafs' Special Teams Stopped Bailing Them Out
By Hermes ·
The Maple Leafs are 1-8 in their last nine and have lost six straight. Their five-on-five play hasn't gotten worse. By expected goals it has improved slightly. What changed is that a power play and penalty kill that ran at unsustainable rates came back to normal, and the shooting luck that hid weak five-on-five goaltending dried up.
Evan Bouchard's even-strength goal at 15:34 of the second period, assisted by Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, was the only goal on Saturday. Edmonton won 1-0 at Scotiabank Arena. Anthony Stolarz stopped 22 of 23 shots. Toronto had 19 shots, and Edmonton's Devon Levi saved all of them.
That's six straight losses for Toronto. All six were in regulation, and all six came on a six-game homestand that ran from Nov. 3 to Nov. 14. The Leafs are 8-12-2, and since Oct. 26 they've won once in nine games.
The usual explanation for a slide like this is that the team simply isn't good enough. The data tells a narrower story, and one that's easier to fix. Toronto's even-strength play is roughly where it has been all season. The special teams and the shooting that covered for that play in October have stopped doing it.
Key numbers
- 1-8-0: Toronto's record since Oct. 26, outscored 35-19 (NHL API).
- Six straight losses, all in regulation and all at home.
- Five of the 35 goals against went into an empty net.
- 236 to 249: shots on goal in the nine games. That's close to even.
- +11 to -5: Toronto's special-teams goal differential, first 13 games versus the last nine. That's a 16-goal swing.
- 45.2% to 47.5%: Toronto's five-on-five expected-goals share, first 13 games versus the last nine (MoneyPuck).
- -9.7: Sergei Bobrovsky's five-on-five goals saved above expected, the worst in the NHL (MoneyPuck).
- 18 points in 22 games: last in the Atlantic, 13th in the East and nine points out of a wild-card spot (NHL standings).
The record and the margins
Here is the run, from NHL game data:
- Oct. 26 at Calgary: L 5-2 (two empty-net goals against)
- Oct. 28 at Seattle: L 5-4
- Oct. 31 at Vancouver: W 4-2
- Nov. 3 vs. Utah: L 3-2 (Utah's winner came on the power play)
- Nov. 7 vs. Montreal: L 4-2
- Nov. 8 vs. New Jersey: L 4-0
- Nov. 10 vs. Colorado: L 6-3
- Nov. 12 vs. Minnesota: L 5-2
- Nov. 14 vs. Edmonton: L 1-0
Four of the eight losses were one-goal games once empty-net goals are removed: Calgary, Seattle, Utah and Edmonton. Toronto was outshot by an average of fewer than two shots a game. These weren't blowouts. The Leafs kept losing the plays that decided close games.
Five-on-five: not the problem it looks like
MoneyPuck's game-by-game data splits the season at the start of the slide:
| Five-on-five (MoneyPuck) | First 13 games (7-4-2) | Last 9 games (1-8-0) |
|---|---|---|
| Expected-goals share | 45.2% | 47.5% |
| Shot-attempt share | 46.8% | 49.9% |
| Expected goals against per 60 | 2.73 | 2.27 |
| Goals for / expected goals for | 31 / 23.5 | 13 / 15.4 |
| Goals against / expected goals against | 33 / 28.5 | 22 / 17.0 |
Toronto has played slightly better at five-on-five during the slide. The Leafs are allowing fewer chances and controlling more of the puck. What changed is finishing. Over the first 13 games, Toronto scored 7.5 more five-on-five goals than expected. Over the last nine it scored 2.4 fewer. In both stretches the Leafs allowed more five-on-five goals than expected, by 4.5 and then 5.0.
Neither version of this team is good at even strength. Across the season Toronto's five-on-five expected-goals share is 46%, 25th in the league. Its five-on-five expected-goals creation rate ranks 28th. But that hasn't changed during the slide. It was hidden before.
The special-teams swing
| Stretch | Record | Power play | Penalty kill | Special-teams goal differential |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First 13 games | 7-4-2 | 13-for-43 (30.2%) | 40-for-42 (95.2%) | +11 |
| Last 9 games | 1-8-0 | 3-for-17 (17.6%) | 20-for-28 (71.4%) | -5 |
Source: NHL API game stats. Special-teams goal differential is power-play goals for minus power-play goals against.
That's a 16-goal swing between the two stretches. No team kills 95% of its penalties for long, so this correction was coming. The power-play chances have also dropped, from 3.3 a game in the first 13 to 1.9 a game since. On the season, Toronto's penalty kill (85.7%) and power play (26.7%) still both rank in the top seven, per NHL stats. That's how strong October was.
Goaltending: the five-on-five problem
| Goalie (2026-27) | Starts | Save % (NHL) | Save % in the last 9 games | GSAx, all situations (MoneyPuck) | GSAx, five-on-five | GSAx, short-handed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sergei Bobrovsky | 13 | .881 | .857 (120 of 140, 5 starts) | -2.3 | -9.7 | +5.0 |
| Anthony Stolarz | 9 | .906 | .904 (94 of 104, 4 starts) | +0.9 | +0.2 | +1.4 |
MoneyPuck, through Nov. 16. "Short-handed" means four-on-five.
Bobrovsky's season looks average overall: -2.3 GSAx, 18th-lowest among the 51 goalies with at least eight games. That figure hides a split. On the penalty kill he has saved five goals above expected, one of the best marks in the league. At five-on-five he's 9.7 goals below expected, the worst figure in the NHL. Vancouver's Kevin Lankinen is next at -7.6. Penalty-kill save rates swing a lot over small samples. Five-on-five save rates are more stable. That makes the five-on-five number the more worrying one.
Stolarz has been roughly average at both strengths. He has started the last two games and stopped 43 of 48 shots.
The cap stakes are real. Per PuckPedia, Bobrovsky, 38, is in the first year of a three-year, 35-plus contract at a $7 million cap hit, with a no-movement clause in every year. Stolarz carries $3.75 million through 2029-30. Toronto doesn't have an easy way out of this crease. It has to choose between its two goalies.
Who's missing, and who's scoring
From NHL boxscores:
- Kirill Marchenko hasn't played since Oct. 26, the first game of the slide. He had 14 points (six goals, eight assists) in 14 games.
- Morgan Rielly hasn't played since Nov. 7 (12 assists in 18 games).
- Colton Sissons hasn't played since Nov. 8.
- Chris Tanev has played in 11 of the 22 games.
The scoring has narrowed. Auston Matthews has 10 points (three goals, seven assists) in the nine games, a share in 10 of Toronto's 19 goals. Jack Roslovic has eight points in eight games. William Nylander has four points in the stretch but none in the last four games. John Tavares has no points in five games since returning to the lineup.
The standings math
Toronto is eighth in the Atlantic and 13th in the East, with a .409 points percentage. Florida holds the second wild card with 27 points in 22 games, nine more than the Leafs in the same number of games. Last season the final East playoff spot went to Ottawa with 99 points, per the NHL's final 2025-26 standings. To match that, Toronto would need 81 points from its last 60 games, a .675 pace. Only Carolina (.810), New Jersey (.714) and Tampa Bay (.700) have a better points percentage in the East this season.
Takeaways
- The slide is mostly regression, not collapse. Toronto's five-on-five expected-goals share went up during the losing streak.
- Special teams swung by 16 goals. That was the October penalty kill's 95% rate and the power play's 30% rate coming back to normal, and the Leafs getting fewer power plays.
- Five-on-five goaltending is the real weakness. Bobrovsky is the NHL's worst at five-on-five by GSAx. His penalty-kill numbers have hidden that.
- The math is now steep. Matching last season's East cutoff would take a .675 points pace the rest of the way.
Opinion: what comes next
This section is my view, not data. The fixable things are the ones that have gone wrong lately. Stolarz has earned the next starts. He's been average, and average is more than Bobrovsky has given Toronto at five-on-five. The penalty kill won't return to 95%, but it doesn't need to. At the league-average rate of 77.4%, Toronto would have allowed about two fewer power-play goals in this stretch than it did at 71%. The finishing should come back once Marchenko does. What won't fix itself is the 46% expected-goals share. That's who this team has been all season, wins included. The Leafs play in Chicago tonight, then host Los Angeles on Thursday and Columbus on Saturday.
FAQ
How many games have the Leafs lost in a row? Six through Nov. 14, all in regulation and all at home. They're 1-8-0 since Oct. 26.
What's the Leafs' record? 8-12-2, 18 points in 22 games, last in the Atlantic Division.
Why are the Leafs losing? Their special teams went from +11 in goals over the first 13 games to -5 over the last nine. Their five-on-five shooting cooled, and Sergei Bobrovsky ranks last in the NHL in five-on-five goals saved above expected.
Are the Leafs being outplayed at five-on-five? Slightly, but no more than earlier in the season. Their five-on-five expected-goals share was 47.5% during the slide and 45.2% before it, per MoneyPuck.
Sources
- NHL API, Toronto 2026-27 schedule and results
- NHL API, Nov. 14 EDM-TOR game summary and boxscore
- NHL API game stats, special teams and shots (same endpoint for each game, 2026020002 to 2026020314)
- NHL API standings and final 2025-26 standings
- NHL stats, team summary
- NHL stats, goalie summary
- MoneyPuck Toronto game-by-game team data (CSV)
- MoneyPuck goalie data, 2026-27 (season summary CSV)
- MoneyPuck team data, 2026-27 (season summary CSV)
- PuckPedia, Bobrovsky contract
- PuckPedia, Maple Leafs cap page